Comparison of the new Bitcoin (BTC) ETFs: Which is the Best?

Weekly AMA on Instagram - Ask me anything about trading & investing, stock picks, market analysis, etc!

In the ever-evolving landscape of investment, a groundbreaking shift is unfolding that could redefine how we interact with one of the most intriguing assets of the 21st century: Bitcoin.

Imagine a world where investing in Bitcoin is as straightforward and familiar as buying shares of your favorite companies. This is no longer a futuristic vision but a present reality, thanks to the advent of Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs).

For years, the financial world buzzed with anticipation over the potential approval of Bitcoin ETFs, a development that promised to merge the high-tech realm of cryptocurrencies with the well-trodden path of traditional stock markets. Now, with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) green-lighting these innovative funds, a new era of investment has dawned.

Whether you’re a seasoned investor or new to the world of finance, understanding Bitcoin ETFs is crucial in an age where digital currencies are rapidly becoming as significant as traditional assets.

In this blog post, I’ll going to cover the intricacies of these ETFs, explore their impact on the market, and discover what makes them a pivotal development in the world of cryptocurrency investment.

 

Timeline to Approval for the ETFs

The journey to the approval of Bitcoin ETFs has been long and complex, marked by regulatory challenges and evolving perspectives.

• 2013: The narrative begins with the Winklevoss twins’ application, the first of its kind, which set the stage for future proposals.
• 2017-2019: A series of rejections by the SEC, citing concerns over market regulation and manipulation, marked these years. Prominent names like ProShares, Direxion, and Bitwise faced setbacks.
• 2020-2021: Despite continued rejections, the tone of the SEC began to shift with Chairman Gary Gensler’s appointment, leading to the approval of the first Bitcoin futures ETF, ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BITO).
• 2022-2023: The SEC’s stance on futures ETFs softens, with several approvals, but spot Bitcoin ETFs still face hurdles due to ongoing concerns about market oversight.
• 2024: A landmark year, witnessing the approval of the first spot Bitcoin ETF, signifying a major regulatory shift and a new chapter in cryptocurrency investment.

What is the Expense Ratio?

The recent approval and launch of various Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) represent a significant milestone in the financial world, offering investors novel ways to engage with cryptocurrency.

These innovative ETFs not only provide a bridge between traditional investment methods and the dynamic realm of digital currencies but also introduce a new layer of financial considerations that are crucial for investors to understand.

Central to these considerations is the expense ratio, a key factor in assessing the cost-effectiveness of these ETFs.

The expense ratio is essentially a measure of the cost associated with managing and operating a Bitcoin ETF.

Expressed as a percentage of an investor’s assets in the fund, this fee covers a range of operational costs, including management fees, administrative expenses, and other essential operational charges.

For instance, if an ETF has an expense ratio of 0.20%, it means that for every $100 you invest in the ETF, you would pay 20 cents annually in operational fees.

These fees are automatically deducted from the assets of the fund, affecting the overall returns on your investment.

The expense ratio is a critical factor for investors to consider, as it directly impacts the profitability of their investment.

Lower expense ratios generally mean lower costs for the investor, making such ETFs potentially more attractive for those looking to maximize their investment returns.

 

Comparison of Various Bitcoin ETFs

This aims to provide a detailed analysis of each ETF, including their fee structures, management styles, and overall investment appeal.

1. Bitwise Bitcoin ETF (BITB)

• Expense Ratio: At 0.20%, BITB stands out as the most cost-effective option. This is considerably lower than many commodity ETFs and even some broad stock index funds.
• Fee Waiver: An attractive feature is its six-month fee waiver for the first $1 billion in assets, essentially allowing early investors to engage with the fund without any immediate cost.
• Analysis: BITB is an excellent option for those looking for cost-effective exposure to Bitcoin. The low fee, combined with the temporary waiver, makes it especially appealing for new investors or those looking to maximize short-term investments.

2. Ark 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (ARKB)

• Expense Ratio: With a fee of 0.21%, ARKB is just marginally more expensive than BITB.
• Partnership Advantage: Its collaboration with 21Shares, known for its cryptocurrency expertise, adds a layer of credibility and experience.
• Analysis: ARKB is suited for investors who value a blend of low cost and expert management. The slight increase in fees over BITB might be justified by the partnership’s potential to offer a more nuanced approach to Bitcoin investment.

3. iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT)

• Expense Ratio: Set at 0.25%, IBIT’s cost is slightly higher but still competitive.
• Management: Managed by BlackRock, it provides a blend of traditional investment management expertise with new-age cryptocurrency exposure.
• Analysis: Ideal for investors seeking a balance between innovative cryptocurrency investment and the reliability of a seasoned asset manager like BlackRock. The slightly higher fee is a trade-off for this unique combination.

4. Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC)

• Expense Ratio: Post-transition to an ETF, the fee is reduced to 1.5%, still the highest among its peers.
• Track Record: With a 10-year history and a substantial asset base, GBTC offers stability and market confidence.
• Analysis: GBTC’s higher fee might be a deterrent for some, but it could be justified for investors who value long-term stability and a proven track record. The fee reduction indicates a response to market competition, albeit remaining on the higher end.

5. Hashdex Bitcoin ETF (DEFI)

• Expense Ratio: Initially a futures fund, DEFI now charges 0.94%.
• Strategy Change: The shift from futures to a traditional ETF structure might attract investors looking for direct Bitcoin exposure.
• Analysis: DEFI stands out for investors seeking a more conventional ETF structure with a crypto focus. The higher fee, however, may limit its appeal compared to more cost-effective options.

6. Valkyrie Bitcoin ETF (BRRR)

• Expense Ratio: Initially set at 0.49%, later adjusted to 0.25%.
• Fee Waiver: The temporary waiver adds to its attractiveness for early adopters.
• Analysis: BRRR’s fee adjustment reflects market competitiveness, making it an attractive choice for investors looking for lower-cost options. The temporary fee waiver is a bonus for early investors

7. Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC)

• Expense Ratio: 0.25%
• Management Style: Leveraging Fidelity’s extensive experience in asset management, FBTC likely employs a disciplined investment approach, combining rigorous research with active management to navigate the volatile Bitcoin market.
• Analysis: FBTC stands out for investors who value the backing of a venerable institution like Fidelity, known for its investor-friendly practices and robust investment platforms. The moderate expense ratio makes it an attractive option for those seeking a blend of reliability and accessibility in the crypto space.

8. VanEck Bitcoin Trust (HODL)

• Expense Ratio: 0.25%
• Management Style: VanEck is recognized for its pioneering ETFs and innovative investment solutions. The HODL ETF is expected to reflect this innovation, likely focusing on strategic asset allocation to optimize returns from the Bitcoin market.
• Analysis: Ideal for investors looking for an innovative approach to Bitcoin investment. The trust’s expense ratio suggests that it’s competitively priced, aimed at providing value to investors keen on tapping into Bitcoin through a well-established ETF provider.

9. Franklin Bitcoin ETF (EZBC)

• Expense Ratio: 0.29%
• Management Style: Franklin Templeton brings a legacy of active fund management with a focus on detailed analysis and strategic investment. EZBC may leverage this heritage, applying active management techniques to the Bitcoin space, potentially offering a more hands-on approach to navigating market dynamics.
• Analysis: Attracts investors who prefer a more actively managed approach to their Bitcoin investment, with a slightly higher expense ratio justified by the potential for managed risk and strategic market positioning.

10. WisdomTree Bitcoin Fund (BTCW)

• Expense Ratio: 0.30%
• Management Style: Known for its innovative products, WisdomTree’s Bitcoin Fund likely employs a mix of strategic investment insights and a focus on long-term value. BTCW could offer a differentiated approach, possibly incorporating elements of smart beta strategies in the crypto domain.
• Analysis: Appeals to those looking for an ETF that not only provides exposure to Bitcoin but does so in a way that potentially enhances portfolio diversification and risk-adjusted returns, reflecting WisdomTree’s innovative investment philosophy.

11. Invesco Galaxy Bitcoin ETF (BTCO)

• Expense Ratio: 0.39%
• Management Style: This ETF benefits from Invesco’s robust global investment framework and Galaxy Digital’s deep crypto market expertise. BTCO is likely characterized by a comprehensive approach to cryptocurrency investment, combining traditional finance strategies with the nuances of the crypto market.
• Analysis: Suitable for investors willing to pay a slightly higher fee for the combined expertise of Invesco and Galaxy Digital. This ETF is aimed at those seeking a thoughtful blend of traditional investment acumen and specialized knowledge of the cryptocurrency sector.

When comparing these ETFs, several key factors stand out:

• Fee Range: From as low as 0.20% (BITB) to as high as 1.5% (GBTC), offering a wide range of cost options for investors.
• Asset Under Management (AUM): GBTC leads with a substantial AUM, indicating market trust and stability.
• Market Performance: Comparative data on market performance, especially in response to Bitcoin’s price fluctuations, will be crucial for long-term analysis.

Why this is Important for the Crypto Market

The introduction of Bitcoin ETFs is a monumental stride for the cryptocurrency market. These funds bridge the gap between traditional investment mechanisms and the burgeoning world of digital currencies, offering several significant advantages:

Increased Accessibility

• Simplifying Investment Process: Bitcoin ETFs offer a more straightforward way for individuals to invest in Bitcoin. Unlike direct cryptocurrency investments, which require a certain level of technical knowledge (like setting up digital wallets and managing private keys), ETFs can be bought and sold like regular stocks through a brokerage account. This simplicity opens the door for a wider range of investors.
• Attracting a Broader Investor Base: By removing the technical barriers associated with cryptocurrency transactions, Bitcoin ETFs make it easier for traditional investors, who are already comfortable with stocks and other ETFs, to gain exposure to Bitcoin. This inclusivity could lead to a surge in the number of people investing in cryptocurrencies.
• Lowering Entry Threshold: For small-scale or beginner investors, the process of buying and storing Bitcoin can be daunting and disproportionately expensive. Bitcoin ETFs allow for fractional investment, making it financially feasible for more people to invest in Bitcoin.

Enhanced Legitimacy

• Institutional Endorsement: The approval of Bitcoin ETFs by a regulatory body like the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) is a significant nod of legitimacy to Bitcoin as an investable asset. This endorsement can help dismantle skepticism and uncertainty surrounding cryptocurrencies.
• Increasing Market Stability: With institutional players involved, the crypto market is likely to experience less volatility. Institutional investors tend to make more calculated and long-term investment decisions, as opposed to the often speculative and rapid trading patterns seen in individual crypto traders.
• Boosting Investor Confidence: The regulatory oversight that comes with SEC-approved ETFs provides a sense of security to investors. It assures them that the ETFs adhere to certain standards of transparency and compliance, reducing the perceived risk of investing in cryptocurrencies.

Diversification of Investment Options

• Varied Fee Structures: The emergence of Bitcoin ETFs has introduced various fee structures, catering to different types of investors. From low-cost ETFs for cost-conscious investors to more premium options that offer additional services or perceived stability, investors can choose based on their financial strategy.
• Different Management Styles: Bitcoin ETFs come with a range of management styles, from actively managed funds that aim to outperform the market, to passive funds that simply track the Bitcoin market. This diversity allows investors to align their investments with their risk appetite and investment philosophy.
• Portfolio Diversification: For investors looking to diversify their portfolio, Bitcoin ETFs provide an accessible way to include cryptocurrency exposure without the need for direct investment in digital currencies. This diversification can potentially reduce risk and improve the overall performance of their investment portfolio.

Which is the Best for Investing?

Determining the “best” Bitcoin ETF depends on individual investment goals and preferences.

For cost-conscious investors, Bitwise Bitcoin ETF (BITB) offers the lowest expense ratio, coupled with a temporary fee waiver.

If historical performance and size are significant, Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) presents a compelling option despite its higher fee, due to its established track record.

Investors should also consider the nuances of each fund, including management style, custodial arrangements, and the underlying approach to Bitcoin investment (futures vs. spot).

Personally, I have chosen to go with ARKB and IBIT, after weighing both the market capitalization and expense ratios.

Concluding Thoughts

As we’ve explored, the launch of Bitcoin ETFs marks a watershed moment in the fusion of traditional finance and the burgeoning world of cryptocurrencies.

Looking beyond the numbers, the significance of Bitcoin ETFs extends to the broader financial landscape. The SEC’s approval not only legitimizes cryptocurrency as a viable investment option but also paves the way for future innovations and potentially more cryptocurrency-based financial products. With increased accessibility and a familiar investment framework, Bitcoin ETFs could usher in a new wave of investors, contributing to the maturation and stabilization of the crypto market.

However, as with any investment, it’s crucial to approach Bitcoin ETFs with a balanced perspective.

While they offer convenience and accessibility, the inherent volatility of Bitcoin and regulatory uncertainties remain key factors to consider:

1. How will the inclusion of Bitcoin ETFs in mainstream investment portfolios shape the future of cryptocurrency regulations and adoption?
2. Could the introduction of Bitcoin ETFs be the catalyst for a broader acceptance and integration of other digital assets into traditional financial markets?

Let me know in the comments below.

 

New to Trading? Make your first live trade today in this workshop! Meet Spencer live for 3 hours of hands-on training! No prior experience required! Learn all the basics of trading, and step-by-step guidance to make your first trade!

If you're looking for the best trading opportunities every day across various markets, and don't want to spend hours doing the research yourself, check out our private Telegram channel!