The Limitations of Candlestick Patterns

Weekly AMA on Instagram - Ask me anything about trading & investing, stock picks, market analysis, etc!

In this blog post, we delve into the world of candlestick charting and its role in technical analysis.

We will explore why candlesticks are so intertwined with market analysis and look at other ways to view price data beyond traditional Japanese candlestick charts.

By the end of this blog post, you’ll have a better understanding of how to choose the most effective charting method for your trading strategy and personality.

As you read, take note of what resonates with you and give it a try.

Japanese Candlesticks

Candlesticks are a cornerstone of financial market analysis.

They have made trading and investing more accessible to the average person.

With time and practice, anyone can understand and use them effectively.

The most common form of candlestick charting is the traditional Japanese candlestick chart.

This method dates back to the Meiji period in Japan in the late 1800s.

It has stood the test of time due to its accuracy and efficiency.

Candlestick charts clearly present four key data points over any given timeframe: the opening price, the highest and lowest prices reached, and the closing price.

These charts, often referred to as OHLC (Open, High, Low, Close) charts, offer a comprehensive view of market activity.

Advantages of Candlestick Charting

Candlesticks can represent any time period and any asset, limited only by the data available.

They provide a full picture of price movements, making them one of the most accurate and visually appealing charting methods.

The simplicity and flexibility of candlestick charts make them easy to understand, even for beginners.

Most technical indicators are designed to work best with candlestick charts, making them essential for many trading strategies.

Candlesticks are excellent for revealing market sentiment and psychology, helping traders gauge who is in control—buyers or sellers.

Their clear and structured format makes candlesticks easy to code for automated trading systems.

Disadvantages of Candlestick Charting

Candlesticks can clutter charts with too much data, which may not be necessary for all trading strategies.

The accessibility of candlestick charts can lead to overconfidence in simplistic trading systems, which might not hold up in complex market conditions.

Candlestick patterns can encourage traders to see patterns and meaning in random data, leading to poor trading decisions.

The ease of customization and the visually engaging nature of candlestick charts can cause traders to spend too much time analyzing them without making effective trading decisions.

Without real-time observation, traders can’t discern whether a candlestick’s high or low came first, leading to potential misinterpretations.

Candlestick charts often display gaps between periods, which can obscure market trends and add unnecessary noise to the analysis.

Alternative Charting Methods

Charting by Time

1. Candlestick Charts

Candlestick charts display OHLC data over a set time period per candle.

This method is highly customizable and shows the most price data but can be overwhelming and lead to analysis paralysis.

2. Line Graphs

Line graphs are great for clarity and comparisons.

They display only the closing price for each period, making it easy to spot trends and key levels but lacking detailed price action data.

3. Area Charts

Area charts are similar to line charts but with shaded areas to emphasize changes.

They are useful for spotting support and resistance but only show closing prices.

4. Bar Charts

Bar charts display OHLC data like candlesticks but are thinner, allowing more data to be seen at once.

They are excellent for condensing information but can be skewed by extreme price movements.

Charting Without Time

Some traders argue that time is just another indicator.

By focusing solely on price movements relative to volume or volatility, they can achieve a clearer view of market activity.

Below are examples of charts that facilitate this trading philosophy.

1. Line Break

Line break charts are great indicators of momentum.

Each bar is called a “line.”

A new line is formed if the new close is higher than the current close or lower than the close of the previous three bars.

The user can change this number to any number of bars in the past.

2. Kagi Charts

Kagi charts are a fancy line chart with a formula.

They are customizable, allowing traders to focus on price data and movements regardless of time.

Kagi charts are excellent for visualizing momentum but may be complex for beginners and unsuitable for short-term trading.

3. Renko Blocks

Renko blocks represent price movements of a set number of pips, filtering out noise and emphasizing trends.

They are clean and visually appealing but hide a lot of data and are not ideal for price action patterns.

4. Point & Figure

Point & figure charts are similar to Renko blocks, using Xs and Os to represent bullish and bearish movements.

They make trends easy to spot but can look noisier than other charts that serve a similar function.

Chartless Trading

Some traders opt not to use charts at all, relying instead on other forms of data and analysis.

Quantitative Trading

Quantitative traders use algorithms and screeners to filter securities based on various criteria.

This allows for rapid decision-making without the biases introduced by visual charts.

Social Sentiment Trading

Social sentiment traders use social media trends, news, and other societal indicators to inform their trades.

This often bypasses traditional chart analysis.

Price Ladders

Price ladders display real-time price and volume data, allowing traders to see the order flow and make quick decisions based on market depth.

They are popular among scalpers and day traders.

Pure Fundamental Trading

Pure fundamental traders focus solely on economic and fundamental drivers.

They make decisions based on data rather than charts, which may be irrelevant at their scale of trading.

Concluding Thoughts

The effectiveness of a trading strategy often depends on how price data is viewed and interpreted.

While candlestick charts offer a wealth of information and flexibility, they may not be suitable for every trader or strategy.

Exploring alternative charting methods or even abandoning charts altogether in favor of quantitative or fundamental analysis can provide new insights and improve trading performance.

Ultimately, the key is to choose a method that aligns with your trading goals and stick to a disciplined plan, recognizing that technical analysis is just one piece of the larger trading puzzle.

New to Trading? Make your first live trade today in this workshop! Meet Spencer live for 3 hours of hands-on training! No prior experience required! Learn all the basics of trading, and step-by-step guidance to make your first trade!

If you're looking for the best trading opportunities every day across various markets, and don't want to spend hours doing the research yourself, check out our private Telegram channel!