How to Manage Losing Trades: Why We Hold Losers Too Long and How to Let Go Sooner

Want the daily routine? Get the free 15-Minute Swing Trader’s Checklist. Get it free →

By Spencer Li, CFTe · Last updated: 26 October 2026

To manage losing trades, decide what you are willing to lose before you enter, put your stop-loss where your plan says it goes, and when price reaches it, take the loss and move on. That means no moving the stop, no averaging down and no waiting for breakeven. The rules are simple. The psychology is hard. Most new traders sell a small winner quickly and hold a loser in the hope that it comes back, which leaves them with small wins and large losses, the exact shape that slowly drains an account.

I first wrote about this in July 2021.

Would you take a coin toss that pays $150 and costs $100?

Daniel Kahneman, the psychologist who won a Nobel Prize in economics, uses this question in Thinking, Fast and Slow. Heads, you win $150. Tails, you lose $100. On average the bet pays you, and most people still turn it down.

When he asked people how big the win would have to be before they would accept an even chance of losing $100, the answer for many of them was about $200, twice as much as the loss. In the same book he puts the measured “loss aversion ratio” at “usually in the range of 1.5 to 2.5”. So a loss tends to hurt roughly twice as much as the same gain feels good.

Now try the two questions from my 2021 post.

Question 1, profits. Pick one: a sure profit of $1,000, or a 50% chance of $2,000 and a 50% chance of nothing.

Question 2, losses. Pick one: a sure loss of $1,000, or a 50% chance of losing $2,000 and a 50% chance of losing nothing.

On paper, each pair is identical. For the first one, 50% × $2,000 + 50% × $0 = $1,000, which is exactly the sure profit. For the second one, 50% × −$2,000 + 50% × $0 = −$1,000, which is exactly the sure loss.

Yet most people take the certain $1,000 in question 1 and the gamble in question 2. When we are ahead we grab the certainty, and when we are behind we reach for the gamble that might make the loss disappear.

I should correct one thing from 2021. Back then I put both choices down to loss aversion. Kahneman separates them, and the curve above shows why. Loss aversion is the steeper slope on the losing side, which makes us refuse bets that mix a win with a loss. The gamble in question 2 comes from the curve flattening out the further you go into losses. The second $1,000 of pain feels smaller than the first, which is why a sure loss feels worse than a bigger loss that is only possible.

Why do traders sell winners early and ride losers too long?

In 1985 two finance professors, Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman, gave this habit a name in a paper whose title says it all: “The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long”. It has been called the disposition effect ever since, and Shefrin’s later book, Beyond Greed and Fear, gives it a friendlier name, “get-evenitis”.

The best-known test came in 1998, when Terrance Odean studied the trading records of 10,000 accounts at a large discount brokerage. The investors showed a strong preference for selling their winners over their losers, and Odean found that the habit was not justified by how their portfolios performed afterwards. Holding on to the losers did not pay them back for the pain.

There is a close cousin called the breakeven effect. In 1990 Richard Thaler and Eric Johnson studied how earlier wins and losses change the risks people take, and the “trying to break even” in their paper’s title describes it well. After a loss, people become keen on any bet that offers a way back to where they started.

On a chart, “where they started” is the entry price, which becomes a reference point, and the trader starts hoping, and then rationalising, that price will come back to it. But the market has no idea where you got in. Your entry price has no effect at all on where the price goes next, so the only person still paying attention to that number is you.

If you want the routine I use to keep my own trading boring in the best sense, my free 15-minute swing trader checklist takes about 15 minutes a day.

Would you buy this trade today?

Kahneman tells a story about the economist Richard Thaler and one of his professors, a wine collector later named as Richard Rosett. The professor would not sell a bottle from his cellar even for $100, in 1975 dollars. Yet he would never pay more than $35 for a bottle of the same quality. Between $35 and $100 he would neither buy nor sell. Simply owning the bottle seemed to make it worth more to him.

A losing position does the same thing to a trader. Once it is yours, it stops being a trade on a chart and becomes something you would have to give up. So in 2021 I suggested one question to ask: “If you didn’t have a position now, would you open a new one?”

The answer sorts most situations quite quickly. Suppose price has fallen through your stop. Then your analysis has been shown to be wrong, the odds are now against you, and you would not open the trade fresh, so there is no reason to keep holding it.

Now suppose price fell, never touched your stop, and then climbed back to your entry. That actually tells you your analysis has not been proven wrong yet. Bailing out at breakeven here, out of pure relief, cuts a trade that is still working, and over time that habit quietly lowers your hit rate.

Have you really accepted the loss?

Before you take a trade, your plan should already tell you exactly how much you are risking and exactly what you lose if the stop is hit, and in theory that alone should make large losses impossible.

Yet it does not work for everyone, and the problem is rarely the plan. It is the person running it.

Most of us have been trained all our lives to chase winning, so sitting calmly with a loss does not come naturally. Imagine you have worked out what a trade can cost you, and you place it. On paper you have accepted that risk. You find out whether you really have when price starts creeping towards your stop.

If you have truly accepted it, you can sit there calmly and wait to see whether the stop gets hit. If you have not, the bargaining starts:

• “Should I move my stop to give the trade more room?”
• “Should I just remove the stop?”
• “Should I buy more, so I can get out at breakeven on the next bounce?”

If those thoughts are running through your head, and you are watching the price like a hawk with your stomach in a knot, the fear is telling you something. You have not yet accepted the risk you took. Nobody wins 100% of the time, so to win over the long run you have to make peace with losing some of the time.

What is a stop-loss really for?

A stop-loss has two jobs, and most traders only think about the first.

1. To keep your losses small.
2. To give you peace of mind.

Once you have genuinely accepted that losses are part of trading, the stop stops being a source of stress and becomes the thing that lets you walk away from the screen. You know exactly how much you can lose, so there is no fear of one bad trade wiping out your account.

The most dangerous move at this point is averaging down, which means adding to a position that has already gone against you so that your average price looks “better”. Each extra purchase multiplies the risk, and a small loss that should have been closed turns into a big one that can ruin a year. It is really just one more way of refusing to take the loss, which tells you the risk was never accepted in the first place.

Doesn’t cutting every loss just bleed you slowly?

In September 2025 a trader on Reddit’s r/swingtrading summed up the feeling: “Swing trading feels like death by a thousand cuts.” They described risking a little here, taking a stop there, and watching their confidence bleed along with the account.

That is a fair complaint. Small losses are real, they do wear on you, and I will concede it with dates. In my weekly outlook on 18 March 2026 I told viewers that we had been stopped out of a copper ETF “I think twice”, and that I would be more cautious on the next entry. On 30 May 2026 I walked through an XLE position, which was there as a hedge, that had also hit its stop, and I said that “we lost about 3-4%” on it.

A stop also has a limit worth knowing. It is only an order. If a stock gaps straight past it overnight, you get the next available price, which can be a good deal worse than the level you set.

But look at what the cuts buy. In that same 30 May outlook I said “the idea is always to keep the losses small”, and to “hold your winning trades”. A thousand small cuts is a bad feeling. One deep wound you never closed is how accounts actually die.

What are the best ways to manage losses?

Trading with an edge can grow an account over time, but you will not be right on every trade, and the number of times you win or lose matters far less than you think. What matters is how much you lose when you are wrong, against how much you make when you are right.

A few habits pull the whole post together.

• Plan the trade, then trade the plan. Make your decisions when the market is closed and stress is low, and stick to them when the market is open and stress is high.
• Accept the loss before you enter. Trust the plan and the downside before the first order goes in, rather than after price starts moving.
• Use a stop to limit the downside, and choose trades where the reward can outweigh the risk, so that your winners can more than pay for your losers.
• Treat an open loss as a sunk cost. Focus on what could still be lost from here, rather than on rescuing what is already gone.

Personally, I think the first habit does most of the work, because once the decision is made in a calm room, the hard moment at the screen shrinks to following through.

Following a plan is a habit, and habits are easier with a short routine. The free 15-minute swing trader checklist is the one I run every day.

FAQ

How do you manage a losing trade?
Decide your risk before you enter, set a stop-loss, and let the trade play out without moving the stop, averaging down or bailing at breakeven. If price hits the stop, take the loss, because your analysis has been shown to be wrong for now.

Why do traders hold on to losing trades?
Loss aversion, the disposition effect and the breakeven effect all push the same way. A sure loss feels worse than a gamble that might erase it, so traders hold and hope instead of taking the small loss.

What is the disposition effect?
It is the habit of selling winners too early and holding losers too long. Shefrin and Statman named it in 1985, and Odean’s 1998 study of 10,000 brokerage accounts found it was not justified by later portfolio performance.

Should I move my stop-loss to avoid getting stopped out?
No. Moving or removing a stop is usually a sign that the risk you defined was never really accepted. The stop protects you only if it stays where your plan put it.

Is averaging down a good way to recover a loss?
It is one of the most dangerous habits in trading. Adding to a position that is already losing multiplies your risk and can turn a small loss into a large one.

Does a stop-loss lock in my exit price?
No. A stop becomes an order to sell once its level is hit, so if price gaps past it, the fill comes at the next available price.

---

When a trade drifts towards your stop, which of the three bargaining questions do you catch yourself asking? Let me know in the comments.

If you want to go deeper, my guide to trading psychology covers why traders break their own rules, and the post on loss aversion bias looks closer at why a loss hurts so much. The mechanics of limiting your downside are in my money and risk management guide, and my free trading guides collect the rest.

And if you want a routine that lets you plan when the market is closed and spend about 15 minutes a day on it, grab the free 15-minute swing trader checklist.

---

About the author. Spencer Li is The 15-Minute Trader and the founder of Synapse Trading. He is a Certified Financial Technician (CFTe) with 15+ years of trading, run from 70+ countries. He holds a B.Acc and B.BM from SMU. Every trade he takes is public, dated, losses left in. He teaches rules-based swing trading in 15 minutes a day, one system for any market.

Education, not financial advice. Synapse Trading is not licensed by MAS to advise on investment products. Trading carries risk of loss, and past performance is not indicative of future results.

Want the daily routine? Enter your email for the free 15-Minute Swing Trader's Checklist.

Free 5-page PDF, then occasional trading emails. Education only, not financial advice. Unsubscribe anytime. Kit stores your email in the US: see our privacy policy.

Want to learn the full method? The Trading Mastery Program teaches the 4 strategies I have traded since 2011. It suits beginners and experienced traders.

Rather follow the trades as they happen? Daily Trading Signals is our Telegram channel: my trade ideas with entry, stop and exit, and every trade is public.

Questions about this post? Ask in the free Telegram channel →

Educational content only, not personalised financial advice. Trading carries risk, including loss of capital. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Synapse Trading is not licensed or regulated by MAS.